Cole’s first girlfriend… was Chelsea!
Surprisingly enough, Cole’s first ‘real’ girlfriend was no one other than his now-wife, Chelsea DeBoer. Cole was 25 at the time she met Chelsea and she was 22.
The fans have speculated that Cole was still ‘innocent’ before meeting and marrying Chelsea Houska.
If you think about it, he’s probably just been saving himself for the ‘right one’, growing up in a closed community.
Looking in retrospect, Cole probably thinks he made the right decision.